Time Restricted Eating vs. Intermittent Fasting: Is One Better for You

photo 1561043433 aaf687c4cf04 1

There are two main ways that people tend to restrict their food intake: time-restricted eating and intermittent fasting. Both methods have their benefits and drawbacks, making it difficult to decide which is the best option. This article will explore the differences between these two methods to help you decide which is right for you.

What is Time Restricted Eating & Intermittent Fasting

If you’re looking to improve your overall health and well-being, one complementary practice to consider is time-restricted eating (TRE) and intermittent fasting.

TRE is simply restricting when you eat food so that the meal times are within certain time limits throughout the day. In other words, people might practice 17:15 TRE, meaning they can only consume food between 7 am and 3 pm. The rest of their day is without food consumption.

Another form of this practice is intermittent fasting (IF), where no food is consumed for an extended length of time. This usually lasts around 16 hours or even one to two days for some cases and has been found to help with weight loss and many health benefits, such as decreased inflammation, lower risk for disease, and improved memory recall in older populations. It also provides increased control over hunger cravings due to regulating hormones related to hunger which can lead to better mental clarity during periods of IF or TRE.

While there are risks associated with any type of fasting, it has shown promise in improving overall health and wellness if adopted safely and responsibly.

Time Restricted Eating & Intermittent Fasting Comparison

On a TRE diet, one can either restrict food to a particular window of time or fast for specific lengths on certain days. With IF, the crossovers between meals are much longer, with meal timing relying more on instinct than hard planning.

Both methods have proven to be effective for weight loss and hunger control. Regarding energy levels, TRE has been found to increase alertness during non-eating times compared to IF. For example, people on TRE had more energy for daily tasks late in the afternoon when fewer hours remained in their window for consuming food. On the other hand, with IF, there may be some tradeoffs between long-term focus and short-term mental clarity due to long stretches without food.

Ultimately, while both methods can help with weight loss goals, they provide different experiences depending on people’s preferences toward hunger control and overall energy levels. Therefore, it is important to understand the differences between these two popular dieting methods before deciding which one may be right for individual needs.

Which Method is More Sustainable

For those searching for a sustainable approach to dietary restriction, intermittent fasting is likely to be the better option of the two. It typically involves periods of uninterrupted eating lasting up to 16 hours followed by a scheduled 8-to-12-hour fast, meaning that there are significantly fewer restrictions on total daily calorie intake overall. As such, IF provides greater flexibility without sacrificing any potential health benefits.

In contrast, time-restricted eating requires continuous adherence to daily specific mealtimes regardless of the overall weekly schedule or lifestyle habits. This can make sustainability more difficult due to its inflexibility when faced with changes in routine or unexpected occurrences. Therefore, while time-restricted eating may be helpful for short-term dietary experiments or day-to-day management, intermittent fasting appears more viable as a lifestyle choice for the long term.

Thus, although both TRE and IF can offer positive results for dietary success in their respective contexts, it would seem that intermittent fasting offers greater potential for successful sustained weight management in the long run.

Tips for People Implementing TRE or IF

If you are interested in trying time-restricted eating or intermittent fasting for your health and wellness, there are a few tips that can help ensure you get the most out of these activities.

· First, it is crucial to establish an eating window that allows you to sit down and enjoy your meals. This means setting aside time in the day to actually eat while ensuring that it fits within your other commitments.

· Second, depending on your specific plan, take additional supplements, such as multivitamins, if needed, to make up for any nutrient gaps.

· Third, be mindful of portion size when selecting meals and snacking between meals.

· Lastly, practice patience as your body adjusts to this new schedule; don’t give up after one or two days if you don’t feel the drastic results right away.

By following these tips, one can begin to safely experience the health benefits that time-restricted eating or intermittent fasting has to offer.


Time Restricted Eating (TRE) and Intermittent Fasting (IF) are popular dieting methods with their own set of pros and cons.

Suppose one is interested in trying either approach. In that case, it is essential to remember to establish a consistent eating window, take any needed supplements, practice mindful portion control, and be patient as your body adjusts. With these tips in mind, anyone can benefit from the health benefits these dieting strategies have to offer.

Ultimately, each individual should carefully weigh the pros and cons of each approach before deciding which one is right for them. But with knowledge and patience, it is possible to optimize dieting efforts and reach desired goals while maintaining a healthy lifestyle.